"Connecting communities, empowering nations: Unifying the Regional and Global Economy ."

India’s growth narrative has always captured global attention. With a population of over 1.4 billion and a demographic dividend that is the envy of many nations, India is poised for long-term economic potential. However, a closer look at the structure of India’s GDP reveals a paradox that economists and policymakers cannot ignore: India is consuming more than it is investing, and that could be a cause for concern.

The Consumption-Investment Imbalance

At constant prices, private consumption accounts for nearly 56% of India’s GDP, and this rises to around 60% at current prices. This means that more than half of India’s economic output is driven by people like you and me—ordinary citizens spending on goods and services. In contrast, the investment share (Gross Fixed Capital Formation), which includes spending on infrastructure, machinery, and buildings—by both the public and private sectors—is less than 40%.

Compare this to China, where the pattern is almost the opposite. China’s investment rate has consistently remained above 40%, while private consumption lags behind. This is not just a Chinese phenomenon—it’s a typical feature of economies in their early stages of development. South Korea and Japan, during their high-growth phases, followed a similar path: heavy investment first, then rising consumption as incomes improved.

The Premature Consumption Conundrum

India appears to have skipped a critical phase in the traditional development trajectory. While per capita income is still modest—around $2,700—our consumption levels resemble those of a more mature economy. This has led some economists to argue that India may have “deindustrialized prematurely”, with services dominating the economy far earlier than expected and industry contributing far less than it ideally should.

This imbalance is highlighted in multiple development indicators:

Services sector accounts for over 50% of GDP, which is unusually high for a country at India’s income level.

Manufacturing and industrial growth have not kept pace, affecting job creation and export competitiveness.

Capital formation is weak, reflecting a lack of investment in long-term productive assets.


Why This Matters for Long-Term Growth

To understand why this consumption-led growth might be problematic, we need to consider the foundations of sustainable development:

Investment fuels future capacity. Roads, bridges, factories, and digital infrastructure not only create jobs today but also improve productivity for tomorrow.

Over-reliance on consumption can be risky. In times of inflation, job loss, or external shocks, consumption can fall sharply, exposing the economy to volatility.

Exports and industry are key for scaling. Countries that grew rapidly—like China, South Korea, and Japan—used export-led industrial strategies to boost income and shift their labor force into more productive activities.


India, by contrast, is seeing a consumption boom without a proportionate rise in investment or exports, creating an uneven and possibly fragile growth model.

Where Do We Go from Here?

If we accept the argument that India is at a similar developmental stage as China was 15 years ago, then the urgency becomes clear: we must grow much faster than our current trajectory to capitalize on our demographic window. This requires:

Public and private investment push, especially in physical infrastructure, manufacturing, and digital capabilities.

Policy certainty and ease of doing business, which can encourage long-term private sector investment.

Rebalancing sectoral growth, with more emphasis on manufacturing and industry to create sustainable livelihoods.

Export competitiveness, as a strategy to increase scale and global integration.


The Final Word: Growth That Builds, Not Just Spends

India’s current growth model may seem stable on the surface, powered by consumption and services, but its foundations are not yet strong enough for the leap toward a high-income economy. The disproportionate share of consumption in GDP, coupled with underwhelming levels of investment and industrial output, raises critical questions about the quality and sustainability of growth.

The next decade will be pivotal. Will India choose the path of investment-driven, inclusive, and export-led development, or will it continue down a consumption-heavy route that could exhaust its momentum before it reaches its potential?